Insights: Alerts
Two Factors to Rule Them All: What DOL’s New Independent Contractor Rule Means for Your Workforce
November 20, 2026
Written by
Drew Williamson
and
Jeralyn H. Baran
On November 19, 2026, the U.S. Department of Labor's Wage and Hour Division (WHD) released a
final rule
that scraps the 2024 independent contractor rule and largely restores the simpler 2021 test, with
some updates. For the first time, the same test will also apply under the Family and Medical Leave
Act (FMLA) and the Migrant and Seasonal Agricultural Worker Protection Act (MSPA), not just the
Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), which governs minimum wage and overtime.
For businesses that use contractors, freelancers, owner-operators, or app-based workers, the big
news is more predictability. Two “core” factors now drive the analysis, and when both
point the same way, that is very likely the right answer. But this is not a free pass. How the
relationship actually works still matters more than the paperwork, and the rule does
not override courts or stricter state laws.
The rule takes effect 60 days after it is published in the Federal Register, which has not yet
happened.
How We Got Here: Six Years of Whiplash
If this sounds familiar, it should. This is DOL's third major independent contractor rule in
six years. The 2021 rule focused on two “core” factors. The 2024 rule replaced it with
a six-factor test that gave every factor equal weight. DOL stopped enforcing the 2024 rule in
May 2025 and proposed the new rule in February 2026.
The takeaway is that federal standards shift with each administration, so build compliance around
the facts every version of the test cares about.
The New Test in Plain English
The basic question has not changed. Is the worker really running his or her own business (a
contractor), or does the worker depend on your company for work (an employee)? The rule uses five
factors to answer it.
|
Factor
|
Weight
|
What tends to point toward contractor status
|
|
Nature and degree of control over the work
|
Core
|
The worker, not the business, decides key things like when to work, which jobs to take, and whether to work for others, including competitors.
|
|
Opportunity for profit or loss
|
Core
|
The worker can make or lose money through business decisions or investments, such as hiring helpers or buying equipment. A worker who can earn more only by working more hours or faster looks like an employee.
|
|
Amount of skill required
|
Other
|
The worker brings specialized skills, such as a licensed electrician or a freelance graphic designer.
|
|
Permanence of the relationship
|
Other
|
The work is for a set project or comes and goes, rather than an open-ended, ongoing relationship.
|
|
Part of an integrated unit of production
|
Other
|
The worker operates separately from your workforce rather than side by side with your employees.
|
The three “other” factors matter less and will rarely outweigh the core factors when
those two agree. Still, every factor must be considered, and when the core factors split, the
others can decide the outcome.
The rule also stops counting the same facts twice (for example, working for other companies now
counts only under control). And it no longer compares the worker's investment with the
company's, a comparison the worker almost always loses.
What Is Genuinely New (Beyond a 2021 Rerun)
-
A sharper line on “compliance” rules. Requiring a contractor to
follow the law, meet health and safety standards (even voluntary ones), carry insurance, or hit
agreed deadlines and quality standards still does not suggest employment. But labels do not
control. Detailed instructions on how, when, or where to work (for example, a required script,
route, or daily schedule) can still signal employment even if called “safety” or
“quality control.”
-
Fourteen real-world examples. The rule now includes 14 examples, up from six,
covering app-based workers, farm labor contractors, and truck drivers. For instance, a driver
who leases a truck, cannot negotiate pay, and has no realistic path to owning it looks like an
employee. A driver who negotiates rates and can realistically buy the truck looks like a
contractor.
-
One test for the FLSA, the FMLA, and MSPA. This matters for HR because FMLA
coverage and eligibility depend partly on how many employees work near a given location, so
reclassifying contractors can change the count.
Reality Check: What the Rule Does Not Do
-
It does not bind the courts. The rule governs only DOL investigators. Workers
who sue can still rely on existing court tests, and courts may or may not follow the new
rule.
-
It does not override state law. States can still use stricter tests, like
California's “ABC” test, which presumes a worker is an employee unless the
company proves otherwise.
-
It does not let contracts do the work. Calling someone a contractor means
little if an app assigns routes, sets prices the worker cannot negotiate, and cuts off workers
who fall short. Workers also cannot waive employee protections, and the IRS uses its own
test.
One upside for careful employers is that federal law protects those who rely in good faith on a
written DOL rule while it remains in place. Documenting how you applied the rule, when you apply
it, helps preserve that defense.
Five Moves to Make Before the Effective Date
-
Re-check your contractors against the two core factors. For each group, ask who
really controls the schedule and workload, and whether the person can make money through
business choices or only by working more hours. If both answers point to independence, document
why. If not, talk to counsel.
-
Look at what actually happens. Talk to managers who work with
contractors day to day. Warning signs include fixed schedules, assigned territories, no other
clients, or employee-style training.
-
Review your “safety” and “quality” rules. Keep
requirements focused on results and common safety standards, and rework detailed instructions on
how, when, or where work is done.
-
Check state law. Confirm whether a stricter test applies to wages,
unemployment, or workers' compensation in each state where your contractors work.
-
Document your decisions and update FMLA counts. Record how you applied the
factors, and reflect any reclassification in your FMLA headcounts.
Finally, resist converting large groups of employees into contractors. Plaintiffs' lawyers,
state agencies, and future administrations will be watching.
We will continue to monitor these developments. In the meantime, for guidance on how the new rule
affects your workforce, please contact one of the authors or your regular Kilpatrick Townsend
attorney.
|